Cover to Cover Conversations with the creators of the best in science fiction and fantasy. If you love SF literature, are an author or aspire to become one, you'll enjoy this podcast.
With Class Middle-school teachers talking about ideas and challenges in real-world classroom environments. Discussions on education, ideas for both parents and teachers, interviews with top young adult literature authors.


scene1024: This is not written by James Patterson. Totally different style. I have every one of is books and...

John Dodds: Wow! After listening to this episode I bought a copy of Daemon. What a book. The most exciting,...

Cam Moor: edit I will say, Carey’s world in her Kushiel’s Legacy books isnt for everyone but beyond the sex as...

WebGenii: Just finished Anno Dracula by Kim Newman – its not eligible for review. First published in 1992,...

Allen: In response to Mac and others, it really does feel like Patterson writing, especially in the Womens Murder...

Summer Brooks: Not to mention the new legislation (supported by US Anti-Doping Agency and the major sports leagues)...

JDV: Interesting podcast. On the topic of an updated bill of rights and “self ownership” I would like to...

DanDanTheArtMan: Wow, there were some interesting topics brought up in this episode, I really enjoyed it! Thanks Mike...

Support us
$ 2.50
Cover to Cover
Our SF/F book and author focused show.
» iTunes
» any podcatcher
With Class
Young adult author interviews, tips and techniques for parents and educators.
» iTunes
» any podcatcher
Text-only feeds
 RSS 2.0
» News Feed
» Reviews
» Library
» Comments
Recent updates, news, reviews, text interviews and more

Good advice? Don’t ignore negative reviews — feature them!

Writing
Posted by Evo Terra on Tuesday, 6 Feb 2007
1 Comment so far...

One of the best books I read in 2006 was Infoquake, by David Louis Edelman. I had a chance to interview him recently. He’s a nice guy, and a smart guy, and one hell of a writer in my opinion.

But as always happens, not everyone agrees with that last assertion.

David has recently posted a radical new thought in handling negative reviews that has been adopted by some authors. Rather than emphasize only the good reviews, showcase the bad as well. Here’s his rationale:

Imagine you’re sitting in the Coliseum in ancient Rome and two gladiators come out of the pen. One of them’s slick and unblemished with hardly a mark on him. The other guy’s got scars all over his arms and he’s missing a few teeth. Which one are you gonna bet on? I’m betting on the guy with the scars. Why? Because a scar is evidence of a tough fight that you came out of alive. It’s a mark of experience. And when we see the clean and unmarked gladiator, we just don’t believe that this guy has gone through fight after fight without making a single mistake. We figure that he’s just too young and green to have earned his scars yet.

The entire post is helpful to any and all writer who will (not may) face comments which aren’t the most glowing. Worth a read!

  • Share/Bookmark

Share this post: bookmark it! | digg it! | reddit! | Trackback link
One Response to “Good advice? Don’t ignore negative reviews — feature them!”
  1. Bad Reviews · All the Billion Other Moments says on :

    [...] posted some bad reviews for his novel, Infoquake, and explains his reasons for doing so. (found via The DragonPage)Share This Tags: Asides , authors , bad reviews , David Louis Edelman , Infoquake , [...]

Leave a Comment
Comment moderation is in use. Please do not submit your comment twice -- it will appear shortly.
Creative Commons License
Except where otherwise noted, this site is
licensed under a Creative Commons License